【禁闻】大陆“新婚姻法” 男人笑女人哭

【禁闻】大陆"新婚姻法" 男人笑女人哭

【新唐人2011年8月20日讯】新婚姻法、房子、产权、爱情……一时间成了红极一时的网
路热词，大陆最高人民法院关于婚姻法的最新司法解释一公布，立即引发了网路男女的
�口水仗�。不少网友认为新婚姻法是男人的�福音�，保护了在婚姻中处于强势地位
的一方，损害了女性，作为弱者一方的利益。

大陆最高人民法院12号公布的《关于适用〈中华人民共和国婚姻法〉若干问题的解释
(三)》，从13号开始实施。消息一出立刻掀起一轮讨论风暴，网友纷纷关注这项规定实
施后，对婚姻、家庭各方会带来什么样的影响。

《新解释》共有19个条文，其中一条首次明确夫妻一方个人财产，婚后产生的孳息和自
然增值不是共同财产。

新婚姻法存在着对于女性朋友的诸多不利因素：1.婚后房产不归于女方，却要共同承担
房贷。2.离婚后，房产权依然归男方所有，女方只能得到相应的补偿。3.假使男方出
轨，离婚后女方没有资格争夺房产权，即使有参与还房贷，也依然不属于女方财产。

郭宪彰(台湾知名律师)：�我觉得比较奇怪的是，假如是先生，因为有外遇所造成的离
婚，竟然，太太这边，她所受到的保障我觉得还比较少。除非它还能搭配婚姻法里
面，离婚可归责原因一方应该赔偿另外一方，这样的概念，要不然，对妻子来讲是弱势
更加弱势。�

因为�新婚姻法�的实施，南京的朱女士成了第一个牺牲品。

大陆媒体报导，8月8号星期一开庭时，根据婚姻法司法解释二的条款，朱女士的委托律
师还在主张她拥有一半的房产权。可才过了一个星期，就在一审判决下达前的周末，婚
姻法司法解释三突然落地，于是那套婚房与朱女士半点关系都没有了。而庭审时已经确
认朱女士的丈夫曾两次出轨。

大陆许多女性忧心，新婚姻法条约将无法保障自己的权利，不少网友直接批评，�婚姻
法司法解释�没有人性，是依强欺弱，发出了�老公约等于房东�、�铁打的房子，流
水的媳妇�等感慨。

反观西方很多国家，离婚之后的女性可以获得赡养费一直到再婚，由于国外信用制度的
完善，女方索要孩子的抚养费也是非常容易的。

举例日本，房贷几乎伴随购房者一生，如果离婚，女方甚至可以获得70%的房产，这样
�显失公平"的法律，却能有效约束日本社会家庭稳定。而根据近年新修改的日本婚姻
法，提起离婚诉讼的妻子可获得丈夫退休金的一半。

网友草帽在[市民论坛]发表意见，他说国外的法律都是保护女性的，怎么中国这点不和
国际接轨了！

另一位网友也表示，中国有那么多法律法规不完善，偏偏婚姻法在房子到底归谁这点上
做完善，难道制定法律那位爷家里有好几个儿子，他首付了好多套房子？只有利益真的
触碰到规则制定人自己的时候，他才会着急敏感吧。

新唐人记者梁欣、黄容、萧宇综合报导。

China's Controversial New Marriage Law

New marriage law, house, property and love ...have recently become online
buzz words.China's Supreme People's Court's release of the
judicialinterpretation of the marriage law immediately triggeredan online
bickering among male and female netizens.

Many netizens think that the new marriage law is a "gospel"for men to
protect their interests in their marriages,at the cost of the more
vulnerable females' interests.

China's Supreme People's Court issued on August 12,"The Interpretation to
China's Marriage Law".It came into effect on August 13.Its release
immediately set off a storm of discussions.Netizens are concerned about its
impacts onmarriages and the families."The New Interpretation" has 19
clauses,one of which stipulates that the interests generated byand
appreciation of a personal property belonging to onespouse is not the
common property of the couple.The new law has many unfavorable factors to
the wives:

1. In the marriage, real estate properties don't belong tothe wife, who
still needs to share the mortgage payments.2. After the divorce, all real
estate properties belong to the man.The wife can only be compensated
accordingly.3. If the husband is unfaithful, the divorced wife is not
eligibleto compete for the property rights.Even if the spouses shared
mortgage payments,the properties still don't belong to the wife.Guo
Xianzhang (well-known Taiwanese lawyer):"I found it rather strange.If the
husband's disloyalty results in a divorce,the wife receives less
protection.Unless it states in the Marriage Law that the party,
whoseactions caused the divorce should compensate the other
party,otherwise, the wife becomes more vulnerable."

Ms. Zhu from Nanjing has become the first victim ofthe new Marriage
Law.According to Chinese media, at the hearing on August 8,according to the
previous judicial interpretation of the law,Ms. Zhu's lawyer claimed that
she had the right tohalf of the property.However, a week later, the new
interpretation came out.The property now has nothing to do with Ms. Zhu.The
court has already confirmed thatMs. Zhu's husband had twice cheated on
her.Many Chinese females are worried about the new MarriageLaw will not
protect their rights.Netizens criticized, "The judicial interpretation is
inhumane,""Husbands are land lords," and"The house is made of iron;the wife
is made of running water."In many Western countries, divorced women can
receivespousal support from their ex-husbands, until they remarry.It is
also very easy for the females to ask forchild support payments from their
ex-spouses.In Japan, house owners have a virtually lifetime mortgage.After
the divorce, the wife can obtain 70% of the property.These "unfair" laws
effectively ensurethe social and family stabilities in Japan.According to
the recent revised Marriage Law of Japan, thewife that filed for divorce
can get half of the man's pension.A netizen nicknamed "straw hat" said that
the lawsin foreign countries are to protect females.How come China is not
following the international standardsin terms of the marriage law?Another
netizen micro-blogged that China has so many lawsand regulations with
loopholes, except the marriage law.The marriage law maker must have many
sons andmade lots of down payments for the houses.The law must affect his
interests,for him to put in such clauses.

NTD reporters Liang Xin, Huang Rong and Xiao Yu 2011-08-20
10:07:48http://www.ntdtv.com/xtr/gb/2011/08/20/a576675.html.-【禁闻】大陆"新
婚姻法"-男人笑女人哭.html