【禁闻】美电揭中共内斗 温任内难有作为

【禁闻】美电揭中共内斗 温任内难有作为

【新唐人2011年9月6日讯】维基解密（WikiLeaks）近期披露美国外交电文，电文表
示，中共党内有军政高层对总理温家宝不满，觉得他作风偏向自由。

�维基解密�曝光�温总理饱受批评但地位维持稳定�的密电，这是美国驻北京大使馆
2009年7月发出的密电内容。内容指出，在2008年汶川大地震时，温家宝不满解放军没
有及时空降灾区，军方声称不适合空降，但温家宝表示：�我就一句话，是人民在养你
们，你们自己看着办。�这句话触怒军方高层。

政治经济评论家草庵居士指出，中共军方一直自成体系，不大听从国务院的指示，而受
命于中央军事委员会主席。在国家体系上，是不允许从事实际工作的总理来指挥军队
的。

草庵居士（政治经济评论家）：�尽管国家发生了严重灾害，但是温家宝调动军队，这
个中共军方就不会听从他。可以看出中共这个军队，是一个完全个人化、私有化，是党
有，而不是国有，所以这是中国的一个重大的体制问题。�

电文说，一名1980年代与温家宝同在中共中央办公厅共事的官员说，温被认为�太自由
�，与前上司赵紫阳有同样的改革思想和价值观，特别是政治改革。温家宝早年曾经多
次在公开场合，赞赏西方推崇的自由民主等普世价值，引起中共老人不满。

外交密电引述中国社科院学者的话说，2009年3月全国人大会议举行时，全国人大委员
长吴邦国在讲话中罕有的指出，中国政治不可照搬西方那一套，加上不少中共高层批评
西方政治制度，以及《北京日报》等党媒发表评论，公开批评�普世价值�，矛头都是
指向温家宝。

时事评论家伍凡表示，温家宝和赵紫阳有不同之处。

伍凡（时事评论家）：�赵紫阳不错，要进行政治改革，他的政治改革，为了维护共产
党的稳定、利益，加强共产党的统治。但是温家宝现在讲，要出普世价值了，那就不完
全是为了共产党了。但是他有没有能力做到这一步，是个大问号。�

电文又说，温家宝被前总理朱�基质疑没有能力治理经济。此外，温家宝也曾与中共广
东省委书记汪洋在产业转型步伐方面出现争执。电文引述一名中国社科院学者的话证实
温、汪之间在经济政策上确有矛盾。

2008年爆发世界金融危机后，大陆特别是珠三角不少工厂倒闭，大量工人失业，温家宝
要求广东暂缓�腾笼换鸟，产业升级�计划，以减少社会动荡，但被汪洋拒绝。

草庵居士认为，汪洋的路线和胡锦涛比较接近，和温家宝有一定差距，在现行体制
下，温家宝遇到很大困难。

草庵居士：�因为中国实行了内阁制，名义上权力都在胡锦涛手中，但是他不负任何责
任。而具体工作都要由温家宝去做。就是说他想做的事情可能没办法做到，但是他要承
担很多的责任。�

不过电文指出，虽然温家宝在治理经济上受到批评，但当时的结论没有动摇他的总理职
位。外界评论也表示，虽然权力可能被渐渐削弱，但温家宝应该可以做到2013年3月任
期届满。

草庵居士：�中国是一个很复杂的国情。中国是中共来独裁统治，所以出现这些情况实
际上是一点也不奇怪的。真正要改变中国，还是需要中国进行整体政治体制改革。�

《苹果日报》5号在评论文章《温家宝还可说可做多少事?》中说：�中国现行的政治体
制，温家宝所掌控的人脉，都决定了他无法推动中国民主选举的突破。但在明年中共十
八大卸任政治局常委之前，甚至在2013年宣读最后一份政府工作报告之际，他还是有
权、有责去说一些话、做一些事。�

新唐人记者周玉林、尚燕、张健综合报导。

WikiLeaks: Premier Wen's Internal Struggles

WikiLeaks recently revealed a U.S. government cable,showing some high
ranking Chinese governmentand military officials were dissatisfiedwith
Premier Wen Jiabao for his pro-freedom style.

The confidential cable, entitled "Premier Wen is underwidespread criticism
but maintains a stable status,"that WikiLeaks disclosed was sent bythe U.S.
Embassy in Beijing in July 2009.It shows that Wen Jiabao was discontent
with the PLA'sdelay in dispatching airborne soldiersto the Wenchuan
earthquake area for adverse weather.Wen said: "I only have one sentence to
say:It is the people who keep you fed, so do as you seeappropriate." This
has angered military high levels.Political and economic commentator Cao'an
Jushi saysthat Chinese military is a self-contained systemthat does not
really listen to the State Council,but abides by the orders from the
military committeeof the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). In China,the
Premier is not allowed to command the armed forces.Cao'an Jushi: "Despite
the severe national calamity, CCP'smilitary still do not obey Premier Wen
Jiabao's orders.It can be seen that the army forces in China are
personalizedand tamed, and belong only to the Party, not the nation.This is
a serious problem in the Chinese system."

The cable quoted an official working with Wen Jiabaoin the CCP's central
office in the 1980'sby saying that Wen was regarded as "too liberal"for his
thoughts and values for reform,especially political, as his former superior
Zhao Ziyang.

Wen Jiabao has acknowledged the Western freedomand democracy on many public
occasions,which aroused dissatisfactions from the CCP's old factions.

The cable quoted a scholar from the Chinese Academyof Social Sciences
(CASS),who said that in March, at the 2009 National People'sCongress (NPC)
meetings, NPC chairman Wu Bangguorarely pointed out in his speech that
China does not intendto copy the Western system.Many CCP high levels
criticize the Western political system.

CCP mouthpieces like Beijing Daily published editorials toopenly criticize
the "universal values," aimed at Wen Jiabao.Political commentator Wu Fan
says that there is a differencebetween Wen Jiabao and Zhao Ziyang.Wu Fan:
"It is true that Zhao Ziyang wanted to carry outpolitical reform, but his
reform aimed at maintaining stability,interests and governance of the CCP.
But Wen Jiabao talksabout the universal values, which is not for the CCP
only.However, it is still questionablewhether he is able to implement
it."The cable also said that Wen Jiabao was questioned byex-Premier Zhu
Rongji for his inability to rectify the economy.Wen Jiabao was once in
dispute with Guangdong PartySecretary Wang Yang on the enterprise
transformation's pace.The cable quoted a scholar from CASS verifying that
Wenwas indeed at odds with Wang on economic policies.After the outbreak of
the worldwide economic crisis in 2008,many factories in China, especially
in Guangdong province,were closed, with a large number of workers
unemployed.

Wen Jiabao requested that Guangdong suspends its planto transform and
upgrade its enterprisesin order to alleviate social upheaval,but was
refused by Guangdong's CCP Secretary Wang Yang.Cao'an Jushi believes that
Wang Yang's policy nearsHu Jintao's, but is at a distance from Wen
Jiabao's,so Wen has met with a significant difficultyin the current
political system.Cao'an Jushi: "The Chinese government has implementedthe
cabinet system, so superficially all powersare in Hu Jintao's hands, but in
fact, he is not in charge at all.The actual tasks are performed by Wen
Jiabao.However, Wen cannot do everything at his own will,but he has to
shoulder all the responsibilities."The cable also pointed out that despite
the criticismof his handling of the economy,conclusions at that time did
not shake his status as a premier.

Analysts believe his power may have gradually weakened,but Wen should be
able to complete his term till March 2013.Cao'an Jushi: "China has a
complicated state as a country.

Since the CCP is ruling China now,it is not surprising at all for China to
run into these problems.To truly change China, a political reformthroughout
China is necessary."In its September 5 editorial, titled "How many wordsand
things can Wen Jiabao still say or do?" Apple Daily said:"The current
Chinese political system,and the personnel connections Wen Jiabao can
control,all determine that he is unable to garner a breakthroughin
democratic election in China.Before he retires from the Politburo in the
18th Congressnext year, or reads his last government work report in 2013,he
still has the power and the responsibilityto say or do something."NTD
reporters Zhou Yulin, Shang Yan and Zhang Jian 2011-09-06
11:18:05http://www.ntdtv.com/xtr/gb/2011/09/06/a584500.html.-【禁闻】美电揭
中共内斗-温任内难有作为.html